A non-compete clause is a contractual agreement between an employer and an employee that restricts the employee’s ability to work for competitors or start a competing business after leaving the company. These clauses are designed to protect trade secrets, proprietary information, and company relationships. However, they can also limit workers’ freedom to earn a living, especially in specialized fields or small industries.
Employers often include non-compete clauses in offer letters, employment contracts, or severance agreements. The terms usually specify how long the restriction lasts, where it applies geographically, and what type of work is restricted. The more restrictive the agreement, the more likely it is to face legal scrutiny.
The legality of non-compete clauses depends heavily on the state where the employee works. Some states, like California, have banned non-compete agreements for nearly all workers. Others, like Florida and Texas, enforce them more readily, as long as they meet certain requirements.
Even in states where non-competes are permitted, they must meet three basic criteria to be enforceable:
The clause must protect a legitimate business interest, such as trade secrets, confidential information, or customer relationships.
The restrictions must be reasonable in duration, geographic scope, and the type of work prohibited.
The agreement must not place an undue burden on the employee or the public.
If a court finds any of these elements missing, it may declare the agreement unenforceable. Some courts will revise the agreement to make it more reasonable, while others will strike it down entirely.
Many employees sign non-compete clauses without fully understanding the consequences. These agreements can prevent you from working in your field, even if you leave the job on good terms. Here are some common problems:
Overly broad restrictions that bar you from working anywhere in your industry
Unclear language that makes it difficult to know what jobs are off-limits
Agreements that last too long, sometimes one or two years or more
Clauses that apply even if the employee was laid off or fired without cause
Another issue is that non-compete clauses are often buried in lengthy contracts, and employers may not explain the impact. In some cases, employees don’t realize they’ve agreed to one until they try to change jobs.
If you’re considering leaving a job and are bound by a non-compete clause, consult an employment attorney before accepting a new offer. An attorney can assess whether the agreement is enforceable and may help you challenge it in court if necessary.
To fight a non-compete clause, the attorney may argue that:
The clause is too broad in scope or time
Your role didn’t involve access to confidential or proprietary information
The employer didn’t provide sufficient consideration (such as a bonus or promotion) for signing the agreement
The public has an interest in allowing you to work freely
In many cases, simply sending a letter from a lawyer to your employer can lead to a renegotiation or withdrawal of the clause.
Some states have taken steps to limit or ban non-compete clauses:
California: Non-compete agreements are largely unenforceable, even if signed in another state.
Illinois and Massachusetts: Have laws restricting the use of non-competes for low-wage workers.
Washington: Requires minimum salary thresholds for enforcement and limits duration to 18 months.
Colorado: Recently passed a law banning non-competes for employees making less than a certain annual salary.
The federal government has also shown interest in limiting non-compete clauses. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) proposed a nationwide ban in early 2023, although it has not been finalized. If passed, it could change the legal landscape for millions of American workers.
Many employers can protect their business interests using less restrictive agreements, such as:
Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) to prevent the sharing of confidential information
Non-solicitation clauses that prohibit employees from recruiting clients or staff for a new company
Confidentiality agreements to protect trade secrets
These alternatives are often more enforceable and less disruptive to employees’ careers. If you’re asked to sign a non-compete, you may be able to negotiate one of these less aggressive options instead.